Thursday, April 25, 2019

Whistleblowing and Justice


Whistleblowing and Justice

We whistleblowers seek justice.  The wrongs we disclose may affect only us, or they may affect many others as well.  When we file our retaliation complaints, we seek a very personal sort of justice.

Preet Bharara, former U.S. Attorney for the Southern District of New York (SDNY), describes a legal system trying to do what is right.  In Doing Justice he says we need diligent, honest investigation of possible crimes.  Accusations of legal violations based on hard evidence and the likelihood of being successful at trial.  Fair and unbiased judgment.  And punishment that is reasonable, provides retribution when appropriate, and promises to protect society in the future.

In a smaller domain, the State of California’s Department of Industrial Relations (DIR) attempts to do justice for those who file whistleblower complaints, like mine in 2014.  The DIR produces the determination letter that we complainants receive.  In it, findings and conclusions are laid out.  Occasionally an employer is punished. 

Those determinations[1] in 2017 included a personal victory for Reda Kolta.  Kolta was Assistant Manager at the Intercontinental Hotel in San Francisco.  He complained about long hours and overtime and threatened to go to the Labor Commissioner’s Office.  Three weeks later the hotel fired him.  It claimed he was rude to a hotel guest and botched a banquet room setup.  The DIR investigated.  It interviewed witnesses and decided that the hotel’s criticisms of Kolta were merely pretexts for firing him because of his wage complaints.  After reviewing the case for four years, it ordered the hotel to pay him $69,446 to replace wages he lost while looking for a new job.  It charged the hotel a $10,000 civil penalty.  Justice was done.

Robert Zolensky II had a different experience.  He worked as a paramedic at different companies in northern California and Nevada.  When interviewing for a flight paramedic position at American Medflight, he said he was a volunteer firefighter and might need to leave on short notice if called.  No problem, they said.  Anyway, California law protects the jobs of employees who are called to emergency firefighting duty.

After about a year on the job, Zolensky told management about some potentially unsafe flight events.  After investigating, the company decided his report was exaggerated and inaccurate.  He complained to DIR about retaliation, and an investigation ensued.  That took three years.  The company said he was disruptive and his behavior was inappropriate.  But his pay wasn’t changed, and he wasn’t fired.  Two weeks after the incident he quit.  No retaliation there.  He didn’t offer evidence to rebut the company, DIR said.  So it dismissed his complaint.  Again, it appears justice was done even if Zolensky got nothing from it.

This is how things go for most who file whistleblower complaints with the DIR.  From 2013 to 2017, DIR decided in favor of the only 21% of the complainants.  And in just 26% of closed cases did accusers receive any benefit at all (via determinations or settlements).

Zolensky, though, went further than most of us.  In March 2016, 21 months after complaining to DIR and 17 months before the DIR letter, he filed a lawsuit against American Medflight.  In it, he described more retaliation, including intentionally inflicted emotional distress, than DIR saw.  He didn’t abandon his job, as DIR accepted.  He had to fulfill his volunteer firefighter duty, and the company wouldn’t let him go until he found a replacement.  That refusal might have violated state law.  The company disagrees, but DIR skipped over the issue.

When we lose our cases we question the process and the people involved.  The attorneys we hire and the bureaucrats who pass judgment are doubted.

Bharara is most confident that justice can be done when he praises his staff in SDNY.  They are smart, dedicated, honest, unassuming, likable, energetic, overworked, and blunt in a no-nonsense way.  The best of them believe in the virtue of work.  They don’t take shortcuts, toot their own horns, or blame others for failures.  They work as hard and run as fast to exonerate the innocent as to convict the guilty.  They go out of their way to get to the truth. 

(On the other hand, whistleblowers are snitches.  Tattling is not attractive.  It’s a betrayal, he says.)

He becomes testy, though, when he discusses their failure to convict any of the bankers responsible for the 2008 financial crash.  There wasn’t the hard evidence they needed to convict anyone, he says.  No politics were involved.  How could there be, with such straight arrow agents in charge?  What unclean motivations could they have? 

We’re asked to take Bharara’s confidence in his staff on faith.  If we do, people who lost homes and jobs in the crash have no gripe to make, or none worth hearing.

Reports of nepotism and retaliation against its own whistleblowers suggest that Bharara’s boy and girl scouts are not running the DIR.  Our trust wanes.  We don’t know if DIR intentionally ignored information in Zolensky’s case.  Or if information from his lawsuit would have changed the result. 

After DIR considered my allegations against HomeFirst Services, it agreed with the company no one retaliated against me.  It didn’t mention emails in which Board members decided to fire me, at first for insubordination, eight hours after I admitted reporting two possible violations.  Or an email the next day relating advice from counsel to come up with a better reason than insubordination.  Within two weeks of my disclosure, the CEO and Board had worked out a plan to fire me.  None of that got into the DIR report.

We don’t know whether DIR omits others’ evidence, too.  We can’t be sure if justice is denied as a result.  It sure seems we cannot count on the DIR, or government in general, to reliably hear what we have to say.  And, unlike a Snowden or Ellsberg, small-time whistleblowers seldom attract media attention for even part of our projects.  We carry on our fight for so long and without an audience[2].  It can be hard.

We can’t put stock in the law to provide the kind of justice we seek.  It will help some –20% to 25% of us, say – but we will always be responsible for our own lives. 


[1] Following my public records request the DIR sent me copies of their letters in 278 cases, including mine.  It reported having made 333 determinations and received 2,022 whistleblower retaliation complaints in 2017.  Of those determinations, 65 favored the complainants.
[2] Cf. Stauffer, Jill.  Ethical Loneliness.  New York: Columbia University Press.  2015.

Tuesday, April 2, 2019

Whistleblowers Remain Right


Whistleblowers Remain Right

Whistleblowers are right making in their allegations.  I was.  I think others are, too.  But outsiders can come to different conclusions.

After Attorney General Barr released his letter on the Mueller investigation, David Brooks at the New York Times wrote about our craziness on the subject of President Trump. 

Over the past two years, many people on the left have stood up and denounced collusion by Trump and his allies with the Russians.  They called him out as a traitor.  They risked retaliation by the party in power for their accusations.

During the same period, many on the right have denounced the Mueller investigation.  The claim of collusion was all a hoax, they said.  Worse, it posed the threat of a coup against a legitimately elected government, according to them.  Lefties mocked them and their fantasies.

Now that the investigation is done, evidence of collusion by the Trump administration didn’t prove criminality beyond a reasonable doubt.  Mueller’s work, however, led to charges against 37 defendants, including 6 Trump associates.  Brooks says both sides should take a breath.  They should see this as an opportunity to show some humility.  Maybe some should even apologize for their heated comments.

But, Brooks warns, scandals like this are a mainstay of current political life.  They are the bases for our competing senses of superiority.

The same thing goes for organizational life witnessed by whistleblowers.
After none of my many allegations of misconduct by HomeFirst Services stuck, I never saw reason to apologize for bringing them up.  It seemed to me that I had every right to challenge them although that triggered HomeFirst’s decision to fire me.  So I did.

HomeFirst Board members were stalwart in their defense of the CEO’s handling of possible violations.  They called me Mr. Bleak for my repeated warnings that the company could run out of money in the coming months.  When they needed a bail-out from Santa Clara County (Calif.) to cover payroll, no one called to thank me for the heads up.

Once whistleblowers lose their cases, they usually vanish from view.  Excepting some big names like Daniel Ellsberg and Edward Snowden and a few smaller players who hang on.  Some flog their cases in the courts beyond what good sense explains – Robert Purcell stayed at it for 18 years.  Others, like Jessie Guitron, periodically float into interviews years after being fired.  For the rest, media indifference keeps private how they adapt to losing.

The organizations are more likely to justify themselves publicly.  Wells Fargo, Guitron’s former employer, was hit by fines, subjected to nasty publicity, and lost two CEOs, and it says it has transformed itself. Transformation, though, did not include apologizing to Guitron or the hundreds of others it retaliated against.

It’s hard to know when you should give up a strongly held conviction.   That’s true for whistleblowers at each stage of their projects – when they first see a wrong, when they tell their bosses, when they report it internally and then externally.  It’s equally true for their organizations and for both critics and supporters of the President.

In The Gentle Art of Swedish Death Cleaning, Margareta Magnusson guides readers through discarding the physical accumulations of their lives.  She encourages us to give things up to simplify our living, to move what we don’t need to better homes, and to make it easier for others when we die.

I heeded her advice first in my kitchen.  I tossed spices unused for years and foods with best-used-by dates in 2012.  I set in the compost bin soba noodles, tiny black lentils, colorful dry beans I’d been given years ago, and an expired cheese making kit.  The resulting cupboards appeared to belong to a less interesting person, I’m afraid.

That is part of the problem with giving up our opinions, even after they are shown to be faulty or unproductive.  Without them, we can be seen as less vital, less significant, and less alive. 

Sometimes it just feels better to keep flogging our case.  I kept reporting new problems at HomeFirst even after it was obvious the CEO and Board would do nothing about them.  I fight now to give up thinking that Trump did indeed collude with the Russians.

Tuesday, March 5, 2019

Whistleblowing Need Not Be Great


Whistleblowing Need Not Be Great

Jane Anne Staw’s new book Small luxuriates in minor pleasures.  The recording of one’s departed grandmother singing a favorite song.  A dried leaf seen on one’s morning walk.  A sparrow alighting on a redbud tree.  Sitting with these precious moments can fill us with life in a way that great projects, like whistleblowing, do not.

Staw relates the story of John Marcher in Henry James’ The Beast in the Jungle.  Marcher expects something great to happen to him.  He feels he is being kept for something rare and strange, possibly prodigious and terrible.  It will perhaps overwhelm him.  He shares this secret with May Bartram.  She understands him.  She believes him, and she waits with him.  Years pass, and he continues to visit his friend.  Still the momentous happening remains in the distance.  An old woman now, Bartram dies.  Marcher’s great catastrophe never arrives.  But the sweetest chance was always at hand: their friendship which could have become more.  It might have made their lives very lovely.

When we launch our whistleblowing projects we envision a great product.  Chelsea Manning wanted to spark a national debate on the role of the military in foreign policy.  Edward Snowden hoped to direct the attention of the American people to illegal surveillance conducted by its government.  Michael Cohen wants to alert Americans that President Trump is a racist, cheating conman.  My own intended audience was smaller.  I warned cities, Santa Clara County, the State of California, and some federal agencies about HomeFirst’s possible misdeeds.

When we blow the whistle, we place ourselves at the hub of a great enterprise.  When Michael DiSabato made public violations by Ohio State athletic team doctor Richard Strauss, he didn’t act just on his own account.  As a father, a citizen, and a human being with a moral compass, it was, he said, his duty to bring this to the attention of not only his teammates but also the university, whose values he held dear — the people, tradition, excellence.

I think what often sets us off as whistleblowers is being told we are not so great.  We should put our noses down and do our puny jobs, they say, and it hurts.  We are disgruntled, as our employers claim in defense of retaliations against us.

Cohen turned on the President after Trump spurned him.  I decided to blow whistles after I became fed up with my boss, HomeFirst’s CEO Jenny Niklaus.  The way she led the company into continuing losses.  The way she pushed an unreasonable budget for the coming year.  The way she responded to my discovery of an overbilling of Santa Clara County.  The way she rejected my advice.  None of this, of course, is earthshaking in a company. 

It was obvious to HomeFirst’s development director that Niklaus was an idiot, and he left.  But I stayed, thinking I could overcome her and turn the company around again as I had done 5 years earlier.  I would be praised, not dismissed.

Avram Alpert, who is, like Staw, a writing teacher, recently wrote in “The Good-Enough Life” that our desire for greatness can limit us.  The desire, though, is common.  U.S. presidents, including Lyndon Johnson, Reagan, and Trump, have called America great.  Philosophers have set standards for ethical life so high that few, if any, can achieve.

Rather than the great life, chose a middle path, Alpert says.  That is the one more likely to give each of us the resources needed to handle our inevitable sufferings in the world.  This good-enough life embraces the ordinary, as Staw suggests in her praise of the curled leaf she chances on.

Alpert cautions that the good-enough life is not easy to achieve.  It’s hard work to smile patiently while suffering the routine pains of our ordinary lives.  It’s not always easy to put up with organizational inanities.  Certainly not for me: my post-MBA career included 8 companies, 2 of which fired me.

Despite the surging popularity of mindfulness and being present, the advice that Staw and Alpert offer is not entirely satisfying either.  If we focus on the small pleasures of organizational life – doing our jobs well, enjoying our co-workers, appreciating our paychecks and well-lit environments – we can easily become complicit in the breakdown of legal and ethical norms.  Like the philosophers Karl Marx chided, we would choose to appreciate the world in many ways while the point is to change it.

The lesson from John Marcher, I think, is not to pretend that we are about to accomplish something great with our whistleblowing.  The odds are too much against us for that to be the case.  Still, we must act, not for greatness but for ourselves and what it means to be alive.

Monday, February 18, 2019

Billionaire Whistleblower


Billionaire Whistleblower

Whistleblowers are generally underdogs, not top dogs.  They speak truth to power.  They don’t usually have power.  With the democratization of whistleblowing, though, standards have shifted.  The richest man in the world is now a whistleblower.

This month, Jeff Bezos, Amazon CEO and owner of The Washington Post, went public in a blog post.  The National Enquirer had revealed Bezos sent intimate texts to a woman with whom he was having an extramarital affair.  Bezos didn’t like having his privacy violated and began investigating who leaked the material.  This apparently upset the paper’s publisher, David Pecker. 

Officials from AMI, which owns the Enquirer, got involved.  They told Bezos that more photos would be published if he didn’t stop his investigation.  They also wanted him to say there was nothing political in the Enquirer’s reporting.  Pecker, you see, has close connections with Trump, and Trump has attacked Amazon and The Post, which has published reports critical of the President.

Bezos responded as a whistleblower might:  If in my position I can’t stand up to this kind of extortion, how many people can?  As happened in the #MeToo movement on a much larger scale, others also stepped forward talking about AMI’s threats to them.  Ronan Farrow was one, and Huffington Post named others.

Now federal investigators are reported to be looking into AMI’s and the Enquirer’s possible extortion.  The stakes for Pecker and AMI are high.   Acts of extortion could violate the company’s immunity agreement over hush money paid to AMI by Trump’s attorney Michael Cohen.

Like other whistleblowers, Bezos is principled.  He defends his privacy, and he stands up to scumbags.  Unlike the rest of us, he has a lot of money to devote to his project.  He asked three attorneys to review his blog post.  He engaged bodyguard-to-the-stars Gavin de Becker to help him.  Also unlike the rest of us, he doesn’t have a big piece of his wealth at stake in the fight.

It’s puzzling why anyone blows the whistle on what we think is wrongdoing.  Especially a guy who has $112 billion to play with.

Maybe something like an existential crisis is in play.  Challenges to the essential roles we play set us off.  You can see hints of that in my case.  At HomeFirst Services, I was increasingly critical of its CEO Jenny Niklaus’s leadership.  The company was on a downward financial slide, and as CFO I was responsible.  You might read it in stories of other whistleblowers.  Environmental scientist Joel Clement couldn’t work for the Trump administration after it called climate change a hoax.  It was impossible for elementary school principal Sarah Lynch to do her job when district spending provided inadequate safety staffing for her school. 

In these cases, the company, government, or school district want to go their ways and not the ones we propose.  Rather than simply yield, we resist.

In Dostoyevsky’s Notes from Underground[1], the narrator describes an officer who regularly strides down Nevsky Prospekt in St. Petersburg.  Imperious, he expects others to move from his path.  Having always to back down angered our narrator.  What rule says this officer must always get to humiliate the others, he asked.  Why must I always be the martyr?  The officer never even notices me as I step aside.

Our hero made plans.  He took an advance on his salary to buy fancy new clothes.  He will be impressive.  Walking along Nevsky, he will be powerful.  This time he will not step aside.  The officer approaches.  Our hero stands his ground.  But the officer knocks him away like a ball and continues down the avenue.

But Bezos is no sniveling runt.  He is an officer used to having his way.  He is used to receiving breaks, not giving them.

In this light, the National Enquirer is the whistleblower.  The Enquirer is the one who disclosed wrongdoing – the extramarital kind.  Like whistleblowers everywhere, it exercised its right of free speech.  Standing up to Bezos’ screed, it fervently defended its lawful disclosure of the texts.

Still. raising a sleazy, supermarket tabloid to whistleblower status seems wrong, too.  The Enquirer is no Washington Post.  Unless you buy that free speech means more to it than business craft.

Likewise, Bezos’ defense of privacy rights could be just a maneuver.  Whatever the game, he expects to have his way no less than Dostoyevsky’s officer.

Our claim to being whistleblowers is always contested.  Despite my many complaints, HomeFirst denied I was one and the State agreed.  Even we can find our ventures hard to justify after the sacrifices we make.  While I'm sure the organizations that treat us roughly are scumbags, I admit the underground narrator is a little crazy.



[1] See also Very Bad Wizards

Tuesday, February 5, 2019

Whistleblowing and the Justifications


Whistleblowing and the Justifications

One of the awkward truths of whistleblowing is that both sides think they are doing the right thing.  We whistleblowers believe that we are disclosing a misdeed by our employer.  Our employers are jerks that think they did nothing wrong and firing us was a great idea.

In “Ruthlessness in Public Life” Thomas Nagel observes that the great modern crimes are committed by officials in political, military, and business organizations[1].  As group members, they can do far greater harm than as private individuals.  They can oppress, murder, and steal far more than imaginable by most individuals.

Nagel wrote not long after the U.S. arguably committed war crimes in southeast Asia, resulting in the deaths of more than one million people.  And not long after fraud by Enron executives destroyed $11 billion in shareholder value.  Most of us small time whistleblowers are not involved in such grand misdoings, although stakes can still get pretty big.

A couple of whistleblowers found problems at venerable Walgreens.  S. Christopher Schulte, a Walgreens pharmacist, and Adam Rahimi, a pharmacist formerly employed by Walgreens, brought a false claims lawsuit against the company.  They charged Walgreens intentionally overfilled prescriptions for insulin injection pens.  If a customer required 7 pens, Walgreens would dispense 2 boxes of 5 and then remind the customer to refill the prescription after 7 were used.  The result was that Medicare was overbilled millions of dollars.  Walgreens admitted its misbehavior and agreed to pay $209 million to settle the claims.

Recently Walgreens settled a false claims suit brought by Marc Baker.  Baker saw Walgreens encourage its Medicare customers to sign-up for its Prescriptions Savings Club so they’d renew prescriptions at its pharmacies.  But instead of charging Medicare discounted prices, it used its regular list prices.  Walgreens again admitted its wrongdoing and agreed to pay a settlement, this time $60 million.

Even a man as prominent as Stefano Pessina, Walgreens’ CEO, might have trouble stealing $269 million from taxpayers on his own.  But with the help of the world’s largest pharmacy company, the task was easier.

On a much smaller scale, Jenny Niklaus, CEO of HomeFirst Services during part of my time there, could not have stolen large sums as an individual.  As CEO, though, she employed HomeFirst to grab $130,000 from Santa Clara County and $138,000 from the City of San Jose.  Unlike Walgreens, though, HomeFirst never returned the money or admitted guilt.

For Nagel, these seemingly frequent bursts of immoral action derive not just from the capacity of officials to do more wrong than private citizens.  It comes as a by-product of their duties.

The actions of an official or an organization can appear brutal but still be proper, Nagel says.  Take taxation, for example.  It can be seen as little different from highway robbery: the theft of wages or wealth.  But the morality of the taxing agency – judged by the equity of its actions and its use of money for the common good – can justify the taxation.  When those principles are violated – if taxes are unfairly drawn or the money is wasted – then the ruthlessness can lose its right.

An organizational leader – in the U.S. military, Walgreens, or even HomeFirst – must submit to constraints on her behavior.  She should put the organization’s interests above outsiders’.  She must not use her position to enrich herself unduly.  She is bound to treat members of the organization equitably. 

Nagel writes that an official can sometimes forget the limits on her actions.  She might decide that all those restrictions on her behavior give her the moral cushion to commit unethical acts.  She might decide that she has no obligation to consider anything other than the interest of her group.  Or she might be confronted by such a complex array of interests and responsibilities that she fails to weigh the consequences of her actions appropriately,

Nagel’s list of ethical lapses seems plausible.  Niklaus objected to my concern about HomeFirst’s possible violation of licensing regulations.  She argued that the good done in the company’s homeless shelter should not be lost to petty rules.  She and HomeFirst’s Board discussed how to deal with me for telling authorities about possible legal violations.  Their attorney advised firing me right away because of damage I might do with my complaints.  Niklaus saw the danger but chose to defer action just a little.  She recommended to the Board that HomeFirst should not be constrained by laws protecting whistleblowers.

Nagel’s list has been confirmed and expanded by psychologists, including Dan Ariely, Max Bazerman, Joshua Greene, Jonathan Haidt, and Ann Tenbrunsel.  But outside of research studies, it can be difficult to get into the minds of organizational leaders.  Although I thought I had proof of HomeFirst’s illegal intent, the Department of Justice and the State of California were not interested.

Unlike Walgreens, most companies and officials deny wrongdoing even after they are caught.  Sunoco recently agreed to pay $5 million to settle a lawsuit over 5,000 barrels of crude oil that spilled from its pipelines and to spend money to avoid future spills.  Still, it refused to admit having done anything wrong.  Paying the $5 million was just expedient.

Officials regularly come up with justifications that fit into Nagel’s list of moral failures.  In 1995 José Arias was hired by Angelo Dairy in Acampo, California.  A couple of years later he told Luis Angelo he was leaving for a job at another farm.  Angelo got upset and threatened to tell immigration the dairy hired undocumented workers if he left.  So Arias stayed on. 

In 2006 Arias sued Angelo Dairy for failing to provide overtime pay and rest and meal breaks.  Just before the trial in 2011, the company’s lawyer Anthony Raimondo alerted ICE that Arias might not be properly documented.  Spooked, Arias settled.  Then he filed a new suit charging retaliation by Raimondo.  That case dragged on for 6 more years until a federal appeals court ruled in his favor and he settled for $1 million.

Raimondo, though, denies any wrongdoing.  He claims he took the same approach for many of his clients and it was legal until 2013.  He said, “All I ever did was tell the truth to law enforcement.  Is that illegal?”  With this, Raimondo sounds like a whistleblower.  He wanted to make sure taxpayer money wasn’t used improperly defending illegals.  He’s a moralist.  He’s the only one in the case who didn’t break the law, he claims.

There are at least two sides to every whistleblowing case.  Each takes the high moral ground.  One may eventually be declared victor.  But that is a matter of convenience, not probity.  The judgment will not settle the matter in the minds of all parties.  Indeed, there may be no entirely convincing way to determine which is right, or even more right than the other.  In the end, the competing players may remain standing angry at the edges of the field[2].


[1] Also listen to Very Bad Wizards on the topic.
[2] Cf. Tessman, Lisa.  Moral Failure: On the Impossible Demands of Morality.  Oxford: Oxford University Press.  2015.  Especially her discussion of Bernard Williams’ “moral remainder.”

Wednesday, January 16, 2019

Whistleblower Complaints and the Brautigan Library


Whistleblower Complaints and the Brautigan Library

Richard Brautigan’s novel The Abortion: An Historical Romance 1966 features a special library near the Presidio in San Francisco.  This library holds books donated by their authors.  The books are not published, nor are they available for check out from the library.  They are books for having been written, not for reading.  When the library becomes too crowded with donations, some are moved to a hermetically sealed cave elsewhere in northern California.  Sometimes whistleblower complaints feel like books in the Brautigan library, completed by their authors but unappreciated by anyone else.

We don’t always learn why the donors wrote their books.  An elderly woman spent five years writing hers and said the experience was wonderful.  She donated the book soon after she finished it.  One man brought in a book he had written thirty years earlier.  It had been rejected 459 times by publishers.  He felt old, he said.  Another spent 20 years writing his book in barely legible longhand.  He staggered out, possibly under the influence of alcohol, after dropping off his book.

We don’t really know what sends whistleblowers into action, either.  Our apologists refer to prosocial impulses.  Whistleblowing is a moral act.  We claim we could not have lived with ourselves if we had stayed silent – which J. Fred Alford calls moral narcissism.  We were just doing our jobs.  But our adversaries routinely win when they insist we were disgruntled employees and we made our disclosures in bad faith.

Some of the authors wanted to sum up their wisdom.  One wrote about chickens.  Another about winning the war in Vietnam.  A man compiled seven volumes on the state of Nebraska, which he had never visited.

When we begin our whistleblowing, we, too, believe we have some special knowledge.  We know what the organization did, and we know the relevant law.  We want to put it to good use.  But maybe we get things wrong.  Brautigan suggested the woman who wrote On Kissing had never been kissed.  If so, her view might be skewed. 

Or maybe what we have just isn’t that important.  A girl in a red dress brought a book about a pancake.  But she was only seven years old.  More is expected of whistleblowers.

When one begins a project – a book or whistleblowing, say – it is with hope.  Whistleblowers hope justice will be done, we will get even with someone, we will get back what we deserve, or we will win some reward.  We pray someone will pay real attention to our efforts.  Like the guy with the record-breaking number of rejection notices, often we don’t get what we want.

A difference between us and Brautigan’s authors is the end point.  Taking a book to the Presidio library marks an end to the enterprise.  The writer may slip it shyly onto the counter or slam it down.  Either way, it is done.  But whistleblowing leaks through to the rest of our lives.

For some, the experience can extend indefinitely.  Almost 50 years after Daniel Ellsberg rose to fame he still wins awards for his courage.  Edward Snowden’s life was forever changed by his decision to reveal what offended him.  Jim Holzrichter lost his audit career as a result of Northrup although he picked up a new calling as a consultant on whistleblower cases.  Robert Purcell kept his case going for 18 years until the U.S. Supreme Court refused to hear his appeal.

Even after our project has ended – after we’ve run out of money or energy to keep it going – like a bad divorce it continues to affect the way we see the world.  That’s why settlement agreements usually require the whistleblower never to seek employment with the organization again[1].  Otherwise, if we return we’ll just make more trouble – as the TSA found after it had to take Robert MacLean back.

My whistleblowing experience has stained the way I view charities.  Four plus years after I was fired, I still look for signs HomeFirst will go out of business.  That it lacks the cash to repay its short-term credit line gives me a sordid thrill.  I am convinced other groups are corrupt in their own ways.  Even organizations I have given money and time to in the past and may still do today, they probably fail ethically as much as HomeFirst.

My past whistleblowing opened a distance between me and the world that didn’t exist in the same way before.  A lack of trust is what I have.  Or perhaps I am just getting old, and I respond to having been rejected more than I like.



[1] For example, Jeanette Dawson, Carol Slavish, and Michelle Holmes.  The settlement agreement HomeFirst Services proposed to me contained similar language.

Tuesday, January 1, 2019

Whistleblowing and Social Control


Whistleblowing and Social Control

Whistleblowing is an act of defiance that triggers social controls.  It expresses a grievance against an organization, and it provokes the organization’s outrage against the individual.  The exchange plays out according to the usual rules and has no need for talk of morality, according to Donald Black.

For Black in The Social Structure of Right and Wrong, social control includes any process people use to define and respond to conflict.  That includes criticism, gossip, litigation, punishment, compensation, avoidance, psychotherapy, witch-hunting, feuding and warfare.

Social control varies in style.  Different language and logic can apply.  Criminal law may be invoked or tort law.  The objective may be therapeutic for juveniles or the mentally ill.  A conciliatory approach may be taken in marital, labor, and international disputes. 

Black describes a variety of general responses to social conflict.  It can be tolerated.  The offender can be avoided.  The offended can take unilateral action (“self-help”) against the offender, possibly leading to reciprocal action that mounts to blood feud.  The two sides can negotiate an agreement with or without the help of a third party.  Sometimes the offender applies self-control by giving up or even committing suicide. 

Societies resolve their conflicts in different ways depending on their size, diversity, and legal sophistication. 

But across all the conflicts that result from deviant behavior, the high status party tends to win, Black writes.  The high status offender is less likely to be punished, and the low status, more.  The opinion of the high status person is more likely to be recognized as interesting or important.  Objective analysis doesn’t come into play except by accident.  Ethical evaluation is bent by status.

Into this setup walks the whistleblower.  He is most likely to lose although the magnitude of his loss is uncertain at first.  Many lose their jobs.  Some are blackballed and kept from finding new jobs – like Jessie Guitron, James Holtzrichter, and Grant Timmons.  

Black assures us in the crystalline terms of academia that our outcome was in the cards we were dwelt.  My project with HomeFirst Services was doomed to fail from the beginning.  I was the lesser power at the table, and the minor wrongs that I alleged gave me no more influence.  The governmental third parties were more closely aligned with HomeFirst which receives 8o% of its revenue directly or indirectly from the government.  So they favored HomeFirst.  That’s what I think.

In any case, HomeFirst unleashed the retaliations that others in my position have experienced and that Black describes as normal.  I was fired and lost my whistleblower retaliation case.

If I knew I would lose, what then?  Not just that I might lose or would probably lose, but if I knew for sure that I would fail, HomeFirst would be unaffected, and I would lose my job and some money besides, what then?  What if I also admitted that my motives were not entirely pure, just like HomeFirst and the State of California would point out.  What then?

Maybe I’d be brave and do it all anyway.  For the moral reasons I’d salvage from my mixed motives.  I’d find philosophical reasons to act like Camus’ Sisyphus pushing his boulder uphill despite the certainty it would roll back.  Simple emotions would drive me: the way they pissed me off before I blew the whistle and after.

For some, the loss is neither academic nor fanciful.  Whistleblower Karen Silkwood famously died when Kerr-McGee applied self-help to shut her down.  In obscurity, Eliud Montoya’s loss was likewise tragic. 

Montoya worked on trimming crews at Wolf Tree for about 10 years.  In 2017 he began collecting information from the undocumented men who made up most of Wolf Tree’s workforce.  After his boss Pablo Rangel-Rubio recruited them to work at the company, he cashed their paychecks and kept a cut of the money.  The scheme generated $3.5 million for Rangel-Rubio and his brother.  In April Montoya complained to the company but wasn’t well received.  In August 2017 he filed a complaint with the EEOC.  The next day, two guys hired by Rangel-Rubio murdered Montoya.

When we embark on our whistleblowing projects we think we are unique.  We alone are standing up to power.  We alone are moral actors.  Although academics and support groups have described the bad things that happen to whistleblowers, we think our situation is one of a kind.  But Black assures us the problems we face and our lack of success are entirely natural.  That’s the way it’s been for decades – even millennia – and in all cultures.